...Beauty, cleaning, DIY tips and more - free to join!
   Login   Contact us   Site map   Puzzle Club   Ask a question    Newsletter

The Consequences Of Determinism

Philosophy : Philosophy Articles

The consequences of holding deterministic views are controversial and the subject of much argument.

One consequence many point to is the "dimished responsibility" that determism seems to place on our actions. Broadly, should we really be punished if we are simply forced to react as we do to the extremely complex causes of our actions?

The key idea is that punishing people for actions which are fully caused (and therefore the person had no power to act otherwise) is not "fair" because it is not logically consistent.

However, many would come back and point out that there is still a good argument for punishment, in that one of the inputs into how we react to a situation (the causes) will be our knowledge of punishment if we do something bad or unpleasant. This key additional input may change our response to a situation. Therefore punishment can remain an effective deterrent.


By: Chris

Share on Facebook: On Twitter: TwitterTweet this!

  Reply to The Consequences Of Determinism

  Receive Our Newsletter




Questions about determinism:

Ask question

More Articles:
What is a homunculus
The plant that doesn't want to be eaten - thought experiment
What is hermeneutics